top of page

Hiring Underqualified People Is Not a Business Strategy

Writer: Rich Hartigan
Rich Hartigan
Mar 29, 2025
3 min read

Startups and small businesses love to romanticize grit and hustle. It's tempting to hire someone with enthusiasm and potential, promise that they'll grow with the company, and hope they'll figure out a role that the business urgently needs filled.


Potential matters. So does attitude. But neither is a substitute for the experience, judgment, and support a mission-critical position requires. When a company is trying to scale, hiring beyond someone's current capabilities without a development plan can become an expensive operational problem.


The hiring mistake growing companies keep making

Consider a founder running a $3 million business who wants to step back from daily operations. Hiring an inexpensive manager with no experience leading a growing organization may look like a lean decision. But if that person cannot own the decisions, systems, and team development the role requires, the founder remains the default problem-solver.


The business has added payroll without creating the leadership capacity it actually needed.


That doesn't mean a promising employee can't grow into the role. It means the company must be realistic about what the job requires today, what the candidate can already do, and what training and supervision will be necessary.


Three hiring habits that undermine business growth


1. Hiring for potential without defining the job

“They're hungry and they'll figure it out” is not a hiring strategy. Start with the results the role must deliver, the decisions the person will own, and the experience needed to succeed. Evaluate candidates against those requirements rather than relying on energy or a compelling interview alone.


2. Underpaying for a mission-critical leadership role

If you need an experienced operations leader, set compensation expectations that reflect the market, scope, and responsibility. Expecting someone hired at an entry-level salary to immediately perform like a seasoned COO creates a mismatch that frustrates both the employee and the owner.


Compensation alone doesn't guarantee capability, but pricing a critical role below what it takes to attract qualified candidates can severely limit your options.


3. Promising future opportunity without providing a path

Ambitious employees can develop into excellent leaders. But telling someone they'll grow into an expanded role isn't enough. Define the skills they need, provide training and coaching, create milestones, and give timely feedback. Be transparent about compensation and advancement rather than using vague future promises as a substitute for today's support.


What a smarter hiring strategy looks like

Before adding another manager or leadership position, ask four questions:

  • What specific business problem must this hire solve?

  • Which responsibilities and decisions will they own from day one?

  • What experience and competencies are essential now, and which can be developed?

  • Do we have the operating systems and leadership support to help this person succeed?


A strong hiring plan addresses both sides of the equation: the right person and an environment with clear roles, authority, expectations, and accountability.


Don't confuse developing talent with avoiding an experienced hire

Promoting and developing people internally can be the right choice when their potential is matched with appropriate support and a realistic timeline. In other situations, the business needs someone who has already led through the next stage of growth.


The mistake isn't hiring a less experienced person. It's pretending the experience gap doesn't exist while expecting immediate expert-level execution.


How Riverbend helps owners build leadership capacity

At Riverbend Consulting Group, I help growing businesses clarify leadership roles, strengthen accountability, improve operating systems, and determine where additional management capacity is actually needed.


Sometimes the answer is a more experienced hire. Sometimes it's coaching an existing leader or simplifying the work. The goal is to make a deliberate decision based on what the business needs, not what feels easiest in the moment.

If you're hiring to solve recurring operational problems and still ending up back in the weeds, let's discuss whether the gap is talent, role design, or the systems supporting your team.

bottom of page